Held, not owned: on being the custodian of a gift

Most of us can picture the two moments of a gift that everyone gets to see. There’s the giving itself, with the conversations that lead up to it and the thank-you that follows, and then, if all goes well, there’s the day the donor hears what their gift has made possible.

What I find myself thinking about is everything that happens in between. That stretch can last a year, a decade or, in the case of an endowment, forever, and almost all of it takes place out of the donor’s sight, in spreadsheets, account codes, handover emails and meetings they will never hear about.

After nearly a decade working in that in-between space, I’ve come to believe it’s where a gift is either looked after or quietly lost, and I’d love more organisations to give it the attention it deserves.

Yours to hold

When a donor gives, the money becomes your organisation’s. That’s part of what makes it a gift, because it has been given freely and the donor has let it go.

The reason behind the gift is a different matter. Whether the donor was picturing a student who reminded them of themselves, music they wanted more people to hear, or research they hoped would one day exist, that hope remains theirs, and your organisation carries it on their behalf.

That, to me, is what custodianship means. A gallery owns the paintings on its walls, yet it looks after them for the artist and for visitors still to come. A gift asks something similar of an organisation, where the funds are yours to use and the intention is yours to hold.

The funds are yours to use. The intention is yours to hold.

People move on

I want to be fair here, because almost every organisation I’ve worked with cares about its donors, and I’ve never met a finance officer or program manager who set out to ignore a donor’s wishes.

The difficulty is that care held by individuals is only as steady as their circumstances. People take leave, change roles and get swamped in the last week of the financial year, and when the one person who remembers what a gift was for moves on, that memory usually leaves with them while the gift carries on without it.

So when I talk about integrity, I’m talking about what’s still there once you take the individuals out of the picture. It’s the care that has been built into how an organisation works, which shows up in what gets written down, how information is shared, the checks that are in place, and whether people feel able to speak up. An organisation has gift integrity when honouring a donor’s intention is simply how things run, without relying on someone to remember.

Questions worth sitting with

I’d like to offer a few questions, and I mean them as an invitation to look at your organisation from a slightly different angle, so there’s no need to treat them as an audit. You might notice which ones you can’t answer straight away.

  • When a gift arrives, who feels responsible for it, and at what point does that feeling stop?
  • When a gift is being shaped, how does philanthropy check that what the donor hopes for is something the organisation can deliver?
  • When finance sets up a fund, does the donor’s purpose travel with it, in words the person spending it would recognise?
  • If a gift has sat unspent for a while, would finance and philanthropy both know, and would either feel it was theirs to raise?
  • Would a donor recognise their own wishes in the gift agreement legal has prepared, and does it say what should happen if circumstances change?
  • How much do the people spending a gift know about its story, beyond the balance?
  • Suppose a donor from ten years ago called tomorrow. Could you tell them where their gift stands without a scramble?

If some of your answers were a person’s name, I think that’s worth noticing. It usually means someone is doing their very best, and it may also mean the organisation is leaning on them more than it realises.

Two people working through a process diagram on paper together

Whose work is this?

It’s natural to think of all this as philanthropy’s job, given that philanthropy holds the relationship with the donor. It can help, though, to follow the gift itself and see how many hands it passes through. Philanthropy shapes and accepts it, finance holds and accounts for it, legal and governance set the terms it lives under, and eventually a program, a faculty or an artistic team puts it to use.

Most of those people will never meet the donor, yet each of them makes decisions that either carry the intention forward or let it slip. Each team also sees the gift through its own lens, and every one of those lenses is valid. That’s why I see gift integrity as something shared across an organisation, and why it tends to show most clearly at the handovers, where it’s easy for everyone to assume that someone else is keeping hold of the thread.

Where to begin

A good place to start is with an honest, curious look at what happens to a gift in your organisation after the thank-you, and whether it reflects what you believe about your donors.

This is the thinking behind the Gift Integrity Framework™, which I use to follow a gift from intent to impact and to see where an organisation’s care is built in and where it’s leaning on goodwill. I’ll share more about each part of it in future articles.

In the meantime, you might like to take one of the questions above to your next team meeting and see what comes up.

Jacqueline is the founder of Inclarity, where she helps organisations bring clarity and structure to how they look after gifts.